Friday, June 20, 2008

Real Simple...Eating.

Sandy asked me a great question a couple of days ago, and I felt it warranted an entire post. :)

Her question (condensed version):

How do you feel about getting proper nutrients from just eating watermelon for a lot of your meals. Watermelon doesn't contain much in the way of nutrients that our body needs. The body needs vitamins and minerals and fatty acids, amino acids, etc. to perform its basic biochemical functions.
How I survived 4 years of college.
Before I dive into her question, I have an interesting fact to tell y'all that I don't think I've ever shared on this blog. When I was in college, I was a poor starvin' international student. I did not eat at the cafeteria because I felt I could eat much cheaper on my own.

Luckily, my tastes were really cheap and simple. I instinctively went for a very high carb, low fat diet. Haha. Basically, for most of my college years, other than the occasional eating out with friends or at events, I lived on boxes of cereal (no milk) and cans of corn.

Yes, you read that right - cans of corn. Jolly Green Giant Niblets was my grain of choice. I would eat them straight out of the can, too, being too lazy to walk downstairs to use the dorm microwave. I liked them cold and crunchy-ish anyway. At mere cents a can, it made for a cheap meal. Sometimes, I even splurged and had two cans at a time. Oooooh!

I'm aware that you're probably making fun of me right now, as many of my college friends did. They had no idea why I would want to eat the same strange thing, almost day after day unless they dragged me out for a proper meal at Taco Bell (Blink You'll Get Big Buns!) or Subway (Eat Flesh! I mean, Fresh!).

But although I'm fairly adventurous when it comes to my palate, I actually have always had pretty simple tastes. If I find something I like, I keep going back to it, again and again. And here's the point I'm getting at: No, I didn't necessarily thrive on a diet of mostly processed grains (and when I wasn't on grains, I ate junk, like most college kids typically do). But, I survived 4 years of it, which is a pretty long time.

So back to Sandy's question.
I know I say this in every other post, but please remember, I don't claim to be an expert. I just try to learn from others who have done this successfully over the long term and if what they're doing works for me too, then I gladly keep it for myself and share it in case it helps someone else too.

I don't plan to eat watermelon only for 2 years. :) In fact, when I was newly transitioning last year, I once made a list of fruit I'd eaten in just 41 days of this diet. It was mind boggling, the variety I'd had up to just that point, and it's certainly grown a mile longer since then.

I personally think variety is very important in a fruit diet. However, I don't think you have to worry so much about variety on a day to day or short term basis. I like to think of it more like, "How much variety have I had this year?"

We live in a time when hundreds of varieties of fruit and veggies can be made available to us via import. But if we lived a more secluded, old fashioned life, we'd likely stick to what we can grow locally - which would still be a good variety, just not nearly as vast.

Eating only one fruit for awhile?
I like eating tons of watermelon during watermelon season, first because I know I won't be able to get it during the rest of the year, and second because it is just so amazingly delish. There are other summer fruit that I enjoyed tremendously last year too, but this year I am finding that I am happy on an even simpler diet and have not desired stone fruit yet, although I will no doubt eat big amounts of them before the season ends.

I also find that eating simply on a day to day basis makes me FEEL good. Things digest quickly and my body functions run smoothly. I get to focus on other things I like to do and not have to think about food much. I feel clear, energized and serene. I like to capture that feeling and keep it as much as I can. I also sense that my body does some internal house cleaning when I eat that simply, because it has the extra energy to do so since I've given it a break from digestion.

One thing to keep in mind, is that when I eat watermelon for a meal or for the entire day, I eat A LOT of it. Watermelon may seem like just sugar & water to most, and it is a very light fruit. But when you eat enough of it, then you get enough of whatever your body needs that it provides.

Watermelon Nutrition
For example, Nutridiary tells me that a 15" long, 7.5" diameter watermelon contains around 1355 calories. If you ate only a few slices of it, then it wouldn't carry you much past an hour or two. But when I eat watermelon only for an entire day, I tend to eat the entire watermelon and often more if I'm running that day. Taller, fitter and more athletic people would easily eat the entire watermelon in one meal.

Watermelon, eaten in a sufficient amount, thankfully does contain lots of nutrients! I did a little search this morning and found this fact sheet, (change the amount to 1 whole melon to get an accurate picture) which tells me that watermelon is indeed swimming with an abundance of fatty acids, amino acids, vitamins and minerals!

Cool huh?

For a little extra reading on how fun, interesting and healthful a mono diet could be, I like this article by Anne who is a long time fruitarian.

I hope this helped a little to explain the method behind my madness. Other watermelon or mono meal nuts please feel free to add any thoughts you might have. And happy weekend, friends!

20 rotten tomatoes:

Sarah said...

That's a cool nutrition data website. I like all the details it provides. Watermelon is the only fruit I've been able to mono meal/diet with. I could probably do well with mango (I love it)or persimmons...but I never managed to have enough of these ripe at the same time.

Vered said...

Hi Sarah,

I apologize if you've already answered this question before I became a subscriber, but I'm curious: are you taking any supplements? Thanks and as always, more power to you for doing what's right for YOU. You are awesome.

yardsnacker said...

Amen sister! You had me literally loling at the subway comment! I actually lived off some amazing things back in my post highschool daze! Think, frozen juice concentrate etc. ACK!

Take care,

~Sam

forever*rrraw said...

One of the great features about eating high amounts of sugar from fruit on 811rv is that it can go into, and out of, your system with remarkable ease, providing the body with clean, quick sources of energy packed with nutrition, provided, of course, that you keep your intake of fat under 10% and (if you're new to 811rv) that you guide the body into making the adjustment to 811rv through detox. With this in mind, dietary simplicity and seasonal variability go hand in hand through the orchards of life.

Pulling Daisies said...

Take a quick look at nature. How much variety do most mammals have?! Honestly. Any given primate lives his life in one given climate which produces probably less than 10 species of fruit, and a similar selection of leaves. And this is not a temporary cleanse, this is their LIFELONG diet!! Yes we have tons of variety available to us, but DO WE NEED IT? I think any given fruit has most if not all nutrients available, and so choosing a few different species to compliment each other will balance out the lower nutrients. And of course, your assimilation is SO MUCH GREATER, that you really aren't looking for huge numbers on the nutrient data chart.

Take that a step further, and may I point out that science is in its infancy and only is beginning to understand the workings of the human body. We have recently discovered that the body can convert some elements into others! Let's not forget that ALL nutrients are built from the same "small variety" of life elements, including carbon, oxygen, hydrogen, nitrogen, etc... which can rearrage at will to form new molecules, cells, and nutrients.

Have more faith in nature, please!

Wendi Dee said...

I feel better when I eat more simply, too. I'm still babying myself, however, and eating complex foods until I'm strong enough and ready to eat simpler as a way of life. I'm inspired by you, Sarah!

Don't block me from commenting, but I'm just not crazy about watermelon. I picked one up at the co-op just yesterday and ate a bunch of it today. It was good, just not something that I was excited about. My husband, however, has been living on watermelons for the past month, or so.

Intuitively, I think eating mostly fruit and primarily mono meals is the way we are meant to eat. I know someday I'll be living and eating that way. :-)

Lots of love to you,

Wendi
XOXOXO

J. Kevin Parker said...

Wow, I guess I didn't know just how much nibblits you were consuming back in college when we were dating. I mean I saw the cases in your room, but never thought much of it. I guess I still have some things to learn about my lady. ;)

Kay said...

Watermelon is very filling, I couldn't believe how filling. Enjoy reading your blog. Kay

Michele said...

For anyone not as curiously interested as me, I really want to point out from the nutrition website: A whole watermelon has 28 g of protein! (Protein's the question everyone bugs me about.)

I took a regular old standard nutrition course (the same one the institutional dietitians take) a long time ago, and even in it, we learned that watermelon is one of the most nutrient dense foods there are (commonly available). That means, per calorie, more nutrition than most other foods.

What bugs me is that the "standard" nutrition advice is to have 2 cups of fruit a day. I long to change the wording ever so slightly to read "a Minimum of 2 cups a day"! Small things like that might help overcome the general opinion that fruit is somehow not nutritious.

Great post!

Martin said...

After a 11 mile bike ride on a 103 degree day in Sacramento today I came home and ate an entire 17lb watermelon. I eat mono meals but I don't see any benifit to eating a mono diet. I do eat mono diets when I have alot of something in season. I just don't see that's better or worse than eating mono meals.

Andrew said...

I was a cooked food vegan for most of college and my thing was canned peas. I loved them. Couldn't get enough. I would just drain and wash them but eat them cold.

I think it was the salt that I was obsessed with, because plain canned peas aren't really that tasty.

Paul said...

My carb of choice was ramen noodles. I should have chosen corn!

HiHoRosie said...

Great post Sarah - and I agree with everyone else that the website is really helpful and insightful too.

Hey, and nothing wrong with keeping things simple. And watermelon is one of those fruits I can sit down and eat by itself with no problem. No variety necessary. Sounds like the majority feels the same. :D

Sandy said...

Omg this is something that I would always think about when people asked me if I ever get enough vitamins and minerals eating only fruit and veggies. They weren't so worried when I only lived on chips and white bread..haha And about mono eating..all fruit have a similar vitamin content and are so cleansing that your body will become much more efficient and there's no need of "over-abundance" on "things" such as superfoods. Just as long as within a years average more than one fruit is included. :) By the way..I am in love with watermelon now haha

Swayze said...

Every fruit meal that I eat now is a mono meal. My first meal is 4-8 bananas and my second ranges from cantaloupe to mangoes. I eat my veggies last, usually consisting of tomatoes, lettuce, cucumber and occasionally avocado.

Even just two months ago I never thought that I would be eating mono meals often...I just loved my smoothies too much! Then, one day, I got a tummy ache after a smoothie. It continued to occur and so here I am... :)

I really can't combine many fruits anymore. I even tried cherry tomatoes and strawberries the other day...no good!

Sarah said...

Sarah, what about nanas? I like that site too! I'm glad Sandy's q prompted me to find it. It's so handy.

Vered, I don't remember if I've answered this q before, but I'm going ahead and answering this in a post, probably on Mon morning. I hope that's cool! :)

Sam, I used to have the Subway Logo saying "Eat Flesh" as my computer background. Haha! It appears many of us lived off some crazy things in earlier days, that's for sure.

Chris, that's a good point - thank you for bringing it up! It is always a goal of mine to ease the burden on my digestive system.

Pulling Daisies, I see your perspective, thanks for sharing that. I think it is really difficult for those of us who are still absorbing all this in, to throw away our old belief system entirely and relearn to trust in nature, and I asked the same questions myself when I first started dabbling my toes in all this. I agree, I never freak out about getting enough variety. It'd be nice to have more tropical fruit (other than nanas) but I don't live in the tropics anymore, and the thought of potentially living off of locally grown fruit for the rest of my life doesn't scare me nutritionally anymore. :D

Wendi, sheesh...I'm totally blocking you, watermelon hater! :) It sounds like watermelon is to you what peaches, plums, nectarines are to me... it's okay, can live w/o it.

Kevin, you're such a fibber! The only cases you saw in my room were suitcases with your name on it. Hahaha!

Kay, watermelon totally fills me up too. Although, I find that it exits almost as fast as it enters and I have to pay attention to eat enough of it to pull me through to the next meal. :)

Michele, hope you're feeling back to normal! Thanks for the interesting fact about wmelon being one of the most nutrient dense...I had no idea!!!

Martin, thank you for your viewpoint! I actually don't feel much different when I mono meal over a few days vs. mono mealing over each meal like you said. However, I've never gone longer then 8-10 days on just one fruit. I'll have to try that sometime soon and see if I feel a big difference. But right now I'm really enjoying having one type of fruit at each meal, not necessarily in a whole day or days :)

Andrew, I bet you're right about the salt. That was my thing with the corn too - it was sweet and salty all at once. I'm glad to know I was not the only canned veggie freak out there.

Paul, after I got married I switched from corn to ramen. Haha! I ate the really bad, bad MSG laden stuff from SE Asia, too. It actually made me feel sick, yet I was so addicted I kept eating it!

Heidi, thanks for your thoughts! I'm really glad I stumbled on that website. I have a feeling I'm gonna use it often. As for wmelon, I don't know many ppl (except Wendi, haha) that don't like it enough to sit down and eat a bunch of it as is. What a wonderful fruit!

Sandy, glad to hear that you're cultivating your love with wmelon! Hehe. And, you're SO right about ppl not worrying if you were getting enough nutrition, on white bread and chips!

Swayze, your current diet sounds very similar to mine. Except I throw watermelon into the mix. But I notice that one days I'm working out heavily, I desire bananas more.

Jane @ Kidzarama said...

Thanks for all that information, Sarah.
I was worried that you weren't getting the right nutrients from your fruit diet.

Looks like you know what you're doing.

And good on you for doing what feels right to you. :)

Sarah said...

I like bananas, but not enough to mono meal with them. I may have 6-7 at lunch, but I have to eat lettuce, cukes, or celery with them or after them. I would love to get to the point that I could eat them alone, but I just don't like them that much.

Sarah said...

Thank you, Jane! :) I truly appreciate people who think I'm nuts but can muster up encouragement for me anyway. Seriously.

Sarah, ah, I get it. And you know, as much as I love nanas, I eat them so much already that I don't realy feel drawn to eating JUST nanas for weeks at a time :D. Did you read Martin's comment - he thinks there is prob no dif between mono mealing one fruit at each meal vs one fruit for days on end...his comment intrigued me!

Sarah said...

I found Martin's comment intriguing as well. It's definitely "food" for thought :)